Respectus Philologicus eISSN 2335-2388
2022, no. 41 (46), pp. 120–131 DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.15388/RESPECTUS.2022.41.46.113
The Genesis of Yi’an Style (易安體) in Medieval Chinese Poetry
Oles’ Honchar Dnipro National University, the Department of Oriental and English Comparative Philological Studies
Gagarin ave., 72/1202, 49000 Dnipro, Ukraine
ORCID iD: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-3432-3679
Research interests: Classical Chinese poetry, women’s poetry of the Song dynasty
Abstract. This article deals with the genesis of Yi’an style (易安體), the poetic style of the outstanding Chinese female poet of the Song dynasty Li Qingzhao (李清照, 1084–1155?). The empirical material for this research is her extant early 22 ci (1098–1108). The first part of the article briefly discusses the specific features of ci genre, which reached its heyday during the Song dynasty (宋朝, 960–1279). The second part examines the peculiar features of Li Qingzhao’s early ci, which indicate her pushing the limits of writing traditional Chinese poetry. These features are 1) modification of the classical themes and images; 2) introduction of love and erotic ci from a female perspective; 3) experiments with the composition of ci and their rhythmic and melodic structure. She introduced the lyric element into conventional ci, composing the poems with strong personal engagement. Her genre innovations lie in overcoming the limits and conventions of the genre, legitimating the Self of a poet in her distinctive personal style – Yi’an style.
Keywords: Li Qingzhao; ci genre; theme; images; feelings.
Submitted 26 August 2021 / Accepted 31 December 2021
Įteikta 2021 08 26 / Priimta 2021 12 31
Copyright © 2022 Hanna Dashchenko. Published by Vilnius University Press. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License CC BY 4.0, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium provided the original author and source are credited.
The outstanding female poet Li Qingzhao (李清照, 1084–1155?) occupies a leading place in Chinese literary and cultural history. Her talent for writing poetry was recognized by her contemporaries, and her ci lines, images and poetic devices were highly praised and borrowed by the prominent male poets. Nevertheless, the commentaries of her poetry are full of gender markers implying not quite definite but obvious differences from the male/universal/human poetic ingenuity. She is always described as “the first poetess”, “China’s preeminent female poet”, “the most excellent female writer”, “the finest one”, etc. Nowadays she is still considered “The First Talented Woman through the Ages”
(“千古第一才女”) and one of “Four Great Female Ci Poets of the Song Dynasty” (“宋代四大女詞人”)1.
In spite of Li Qingzhao’s place in Chinese literary and cultural history and popularity of her poetry in modern China, the evolution of her poetic style – Yi’an style (易安體2) – has never been the subject of comprehensive monographic research in China as well as outside it3. Although her ci were included in different collections even during her lifetime4, on the whole, Li Qingzhao’s poetry was not a topic of extended or systematic research until the second half of the 20th century. Modern studies on her writing mostly deal with the reconstruction of her biography by analyzing her ci (Chen Zumei, 1995; Zhuge Yibing, 2004, etc.). The peculiarities of Yi’an style are mainly presented as a part of the more wide-ranging studies (Chen Zumei, 2004, pp. 108–112; Owen, 2019, pp. 383–384) or as the separate articles (Zhou Guifeng, 2002; Xiang Meilin, 2006, etc.). Some scholars use a biographical approach to study her poetry (Wang, 1989; Hsu, 1994; Pannam, 2009; Djao, 2010, etc.) or make an emphasis on the lyrical feminine voice of her ci (Idema, Grant, 2004; Samei, 2004; Blanchard, 2018, etc.).
All the mentioned studies have three common disadvantages: 1) the lack of historical and/or literary context while analyzing Li Qingzhao’s writings; 2) the empirical material for most abovementioned studies are limited to 2–3 ci not allowing to speak about the representativeness of the findings, and 3) the avoidance of issues relating to genre peculiarities of her ci. Consequently, the very process in which Li Qingzhao’s ci turned into something unique, extraordinary and beyond time and her significant contribution to the development of Chinese ci poetry have not been given meaningful and thorough consideration.
It should also be noted that Ronald Egan’s book on Li Qingzhao (2013) is the only one in Western literary criticism that is entirely devoted to the study of Li Qingzhao’s life and writings. His thorough study deals with a broad range of questions concerning her biography, authenticity and reception of her poetry from the Song dynasty to nowadays. He paid particular attention to the social, cultural and economic context and to the analysis of her writings in different genres. However, the peculiar features of Li Qingzhao’s early ci, which laid the foundation for her distinctive personal style making her poems different from those written by her predecessors and contemporaries, escaped his field of vision.
The aim of this article is to study the genesis of Yi’an style based on her early ci. It will allow us to make some general theoretical observations on the development of ci poetry in medieval Chinese literature and to explore Li Qingzhao’s creative evolution. This article is a part of a larger study devoted to the genesis and evolution of Yi’an style, which will contribute to a better understanding of relations between tradition and innovations in Li Qingzhao’s poetry and their correspondence to cultural, social and gender aspects of medieval China.
Last but not least. Though not a single poem was dated by Li Qingzhao, the extant 60 ci written or attributed to her can be divided into several groups according to the information given in four reliable collections (Chen Zumei, 2003; Xu Beiwen, 2015; Xu Peijun, 2009; Ke Baocheng, 2009). I consider 22 ci as her early poetry written during the ten years (1098–1108). The demarcation line is 1108, when Li Qingzhao wrote Essay on Ci (詞論), the first theoretical treatise in Chinese literary tradition dedicated to ci. In this work, she tried to legitimate that ci is a genre of poetry by identifying the same features with official shi poetry. She also determined a core element of the genre and discovered its unique historical past5. Thus, this treatise is an important milestone in the development of Li Qingzhao’s writing style singling out her early ci marked by following the tradition in the search for her style.
1. Ci genre and its specific features: a brief review
Many studies are devoted to various features of the ci genre (Shi Yidui, 1989; Rydholm, 1998; Wu Xionghe, 2003; Wu Zhangshu, 2016, etc.). This part will provide a brief review of its characteristics, which are essential for a better understanding of the genesis of Yi’an style.
The ci genre can trace its roots back to the late 6th century. From the very beginning, its connection with music was its core element as it was considered to be a continuation of yuefu (樂府), original folk songs or poems written in a folk song style. The first ci were composed to the so-called Yanyue music (晏樂, the banquet music), which was not originally Chinese but imported from India, Burma, Korea and other Central Asian countries in the late 6th century (Shi Yidui, 1989, p. 3). Ci with the first genre characteristics appeared at the end of the Tang dynasty (唐朝, 618–907), and during the Song dynasty (宋朝, 960–1279) this genre reached its peak and the highest level of prestige.
Ci were composed to the different tunes with different titles or cipai (詞牌). In early ci, the contents of the poem was related to cipai (Wu Zhangshu, 2016, pp. 60–61). For example, ci to the tune A cut plum branch (一剪梅) should definitely be dedicated to the plum blossom. By the late 11th century, there was a discrepancy between cipai and the contents of ci; that is why poets started to add the titles or citi (詞題) to their poems after cipai (Rydholm, 1998, p. 44). Thus, most ci composed during the Song dynasty have two titles: one is the title of the tune (cipai) – for example, A cut plum branch (一剪梅) – and the other is the title of the poem (citi) – for example, Parting sorrow (別愁).
Each tune had its own pattern or cipu (詞譜)6 and they completely predetermined the poetic structure of ci: the number of lines, the number of characters in each line, the balance between a level tone ping (平) and an oblique tone ze (仄), the place of rhyme (韻), the stanza divisions, etc. Zhengti (正體) is a “standard form” of cipu while bianti (變體) is an “alternative form” appeared as a result of a new idea or a creative twist by a poet. As almost all tunes had been lost by the late Southern Song (南宋, 1127–1279), poets had to compose ci by just using cipu.
Ci are traditionally divided into three forms or citi (詞體)7, where the number of characters is the key difference between them: xiaoling (小令), zhongdiao (中調) and changdiao (長調) (Wu Zhangshu, 2016, pp. 33–34). So, xiaoling ranges from 14 to 58 characters, zhongdiao contains from 59 to 90 characters, and changdiao varies from 91 to 240 characters.
Depending on the number of stanzas, ci can be divided into four groups: mono-tune or dandiao (單調), double-tune or shuangdiao (雙調), tri-tune or sandie (三疊) and quadra-tune or sidie (四疊) (Wu Zhangshu, 2016, pp. 35–38). Shuangdiao is the most commonly applied form. Its specific feature is that the upper stanza (上闋) and the lower stanza (下闋) can be composed to the same or different patterns: in the former case, both stanzas are identical in length, tones, rhymes, etc., while in the latter case they are different (Wu Zhangshu, 2016, pp. 36–37). Moreover, both stanzas are generally in a thematic opposition: the upper stanza depicts the nature or landscape outside while the lower stanza describes the feelings or thoughts of the lyrical persona (Xia Chengtao, Wu Xionghe, 2016, pp. 93–94). This way, the poets achieved the effect of approaching: we “are brought closer and closer to a woman alone in her room as the song progresses until, in the closing lines, the focus is entirely on her and her emotions” (Egan, 2013, p. 376)8.
Early ci were associated with female singers (娼妓) and the entertainment quarters, where these poems were composed and performed. It determined the thematic range of early ci: erotic feelings, romantic love, the mood of melancholy, female abandonment, sorrow for the lost love, transience of life, etc. In other words, ci primarily was focused on describing the inner world of a person and his/her romantic affairs and private feelings9.
However, even by the late Northern Song, the status of ci was relatively low in the hierarchy of literary genres. The first reason is that ci was considered by poets as a kind of template to be filled in with a certain purpose or for a certain event. They “were predominantly impersonal in the sense that they dealt with stock themes and situations: a portrait of a conventional person (e.g., the lovelorn woman in her room), reflections on the passing of spring and its beauty, or the sadness of an imminent departure” (Egan, 2006, pp. 282–283). Thus, the poet’s task was reduced to the following: “to devise words set to musical tunes that could be performed again and again in different times and settings but to retain enough universality to be usable in varied circumstances” (p. 283). The second reason is that ci genre “was still stigmatized for its closeness to the ‘vulgarity’ of popular entertainment” as it used “the themes of love, romance, and sexual desire” (p. 240).
The association of ci with the expression of such feelings and desires as well as its connection to female singers and the entertainment quarters led to that the whole genre was associated with femininity and classified as “feminine” (Samei, 2004, p. 2; Owen, 2019, p. 47). Male poets adopted a female voice while composing ci, so it is no wonder that the vast majority of ci were cast as female monologues describing the feelings of women experienced in love. As “male poets became accomplished masters of one form of female psychology and female impersonation” (Fong, 1990, p. 463), these ci were highly appreciated both by their contemporaries and modern scholars. The outstanding literati of the Southern Song significantly broadened the thematic range of ci by introducing themes on social matters, historical events, philosophy, mythology, patriotism, politics, etc.
2. The specific features of Li Qingzhao’s early ci (1098–1108)
In many respects, the peculiar features of Yi’an style can already be seen in Li Qingzhao’s early ci, but the commentators and scholars “limit” themselves by giving general remarks to these poems and describing them as “charming”, “lively”, “refreshing”, “with simplicity and striking vividness”, etc. They mostly depict her as a representative poet of the “delicate and restrained” or wanyue style (婉約) as opposed to the “heroic abandon” or haofang style (豪放) represented by Su Shi (蘇軾, 1036–1101) and Xin Qiji (辛棄疾, 1140–1207).
During these early years, Li Qingzhao gave preference to xiaoling: 15 ci (68.18%) are written in this short form10. These data can probably be explained by two reasons: (a) the popularity of xiaoling as it was “the dominant form in literati song lyrics” during the 11th–12th centuries (Egan, 2006, p. 303) and (b) her personal preferences as she considered some poets as the experts in composing ci and could take them as the example to follow11.
Li Qingzhao’s xiaoling are relatively small (47 characters on average), and most of them are composed to one of three tunes: Like a Dream (如夢令), Sand of Silk-washing Stream (浣溪沙) and Lamenting the Prince (怨王孫). No matter what ci form was chosen, she used cipu of two stanzas with an equal number of lines but different patterns. Most of her poems (16 ci or 72.73%) have from one to five different citi depending on the collection they are included in. But as Li Qingzhao’s personal collection of ci was lost as early as the 14th century, now we do not know exactly if the existing citi were written by her or just added by the different compilers later.
While composing early ci Li Qingzhao relied on traditional Chinese poetry, particularly Shijing (詩經) and Tang shi. There are three peculiar features of her early poems: 1) modification of the classical themes and images; 2) introduction of love and erotic ci from a female perspective; 3) experiments with the composition of ci and their rhythmic and melodic structure. She began to master the “poetics of tradition”, and her lyric is mainly traditional and based on a system of conventional value.
2.1 Modification of the classical themes and images
One of the most apparent features of Yi’an style is the unusual use of classical themes and images. In most cases, the researchers try to explain it in impressionist terms. For example, describing the popular method of rewriting earlier lines, Ronald Egan compares Li Qingzhao’s ci with poems composed by other Song poets. He points out that poets traditionally practised one of two techniques: “to borrow an entire line from an earlier shi poem and incorporate it unchanged into a song lyric” or “to recast an entire earlier piece, originally written in another poetic form or even in prose, into a song lyric” (2013, p. 326). But Li Qingzhao made it in her own, original way: “rewriting the original and giving it a decidedly new thrust and direction” (2013, p. 326). It is rather difficult to understand by his further words what exactly this “new thrust and direction” is.
The first dominant feature of Li Qingzhao’s early ci are a modification of the classical themes and images characterized by (a) the transformations on the compositional and the stylistic levels and (b) the use of such literary devices as parallelism and personification. Her ci to the tune Like a Dream (如夢令) is a great illustration of those mentioned above.
Firstly, she easily switched between genres borrowing the words, images and storyline from shi and incorporating them into ci with some compositional and stylistic changes. This ci is an adaptation of the conventional theme of springtime lament: a young lady wakes up in the morning and begins to take an interest in haitang blossom (海棠花) after a rainy night. At first glance, it would seem that Li Qingzhao just borrowed idea and images from the poem Too Tired to Rise (懶起) written by Tang poet Han Wo (韓偓, 842–923), who was known for his dainty and elegant pieces about romantic love. However, after a close reading, it is clear that her ci is creatively different and much more complex. Using only 33 characters 12 she transformed this story both on the compositional and the stylistic level by introducing a dialogue between the lyrical persona and her maid. She managed to show the differences between these two women: the former is depicted as a very sensitive, and compassionate person and the latter is described as a careless and indifferent one.
Secondly, the heart of ci is the last line (應是綠肥紅瘦 “[She] should [have said: the] green [is] fat, [the] red [is] skinny”), which is considered as one of the most frequently cited and commented. Here Li Qingzhao used two literary devices – parallelism and personification – thus creating a brand new, fresh image. Parallelism is a specific feature of traditional Chinese poetry and the normative rule for shi. Poets achieved complex effects through it as its sophisticated use could intensify the focus on a certain stanza or line. They had to use strict antonyms, allowing no repetition of the same words (Liu, 1962, p. 146). In addition, the opposed words should be of the same grammatical category (noun against a noun, verb against verb, etc.) and the same semantic group (colour against colour, flower against a flower, etc.) (Liu, 1962, p. 148). In this line, the characters “綠” and “紅” refer to the green and red colours and, at the same time to the leaves and flowers. At that time, the characters “肥” (fat) and “瘦” (skinny) were used to describe human beings (Ke Baocheng, 2009, p. 4), but here they are the features of the leaves and flowers. This combination of literary devices, and the use of those characters, were new, original and very unusual at that time (Xu Beiwen, 2015, p. 37).
Li Qingzhao did not limit herself to stereotypical themes, especially lovesickness in separation, and composed ci on different themes and various occasions: praise of different flowers, admiration of spring or autumn nature, description of the landscape, felicitation, melancholy, sorrow and loneliness.
2.2 Introduction of love and erotic ci from female perspective
However, perhaps the most important feature of Li Qingzhao’s early ci is the introduction of the love theme and the expression of romantic sentiments from a female perspective13. According to the widespread practice at that time, love ci were composed by male poets who usually wrote “about the intimate details of romantic assignations”, described “details of bedroom trysts in language that is replete with erotic overtones” and spoke “openly of sexual pleasure” (Egan, 2006, p. 339). In their ci, women are mostly presented as objects of erotic or sexual desire (Bossler, 2013, p. 37, p. 89) and their inner chambers or rooms “serve as a metaphor for a woman’s sexual organs, making them apt sites for the location of desire” (Blanchard, 2018, p. 68).
Li Qingzhao challenged the traditional practices of the restrained description of female feelings (as female poets were prescribed to do) and wrote love ci with erotic symbolism paving the way to a new attitude to expressing inner emotions and describing female love feelings and being considered as gender perverse these ci were sometimes indicated as those which “authorship is doubtful” 14 and thus automatically attributed to different male poets. Even some modern scholars prefer to consider Li Qingzhao’s breaking out of conventional bounds “not as ‘subversions’ of male conventions of femininity, but as evidence that she was a good poet” (Samei, 2004, p. 73). R. Egan notes that “we today might not consider these poems erotic or sexually titillating, but they would have been considered so in their own day” (2013, p. 356).
The difference is rather obvious. Li Qingzhao, in her erotic ci, places greater focus on the description of a lyrical persona (her appearance, thoughts and feelings) than on “the intimate details of romantic assignations” as male poets do: this is a young woman with irresistible charm and full of grace (in four ci); it is she who is the driving force of the assignation (in two ci); she is full of feelings and expectations but does not directly tell her beloved one about her desires, she just drops hints and inflames his feelings.
Moreover, such a female perspective makes it possible to draw the distinction between Li Qingzhao’s love (romantic) and erotic poems. Ci to the tune Dabbing Crimson Lips (點絳唇) describes the first signs of a young girl falling in love. Chinese commentators consider that the idea of this ci was borrowed from Han Wo’s shi titled Accidently Saw (偶見): a woman on a swing sees a visitor entering the house. Li Qingzhao did not just borrow the storyline and reinterpret it, but created a brand new image: an uninhibited, carefree, and frankly flirtatious woman pictured in Han Wo’s shi turned into a shy young girl with fluttering feeling of first love. This image is emotionally more complex: on the one hand, the girl is playful and carefree, but, on the other hand, she is shy, confused and curious. The difference between these two lyrical personas is emphasized by the image of mei (梅) used in the last line of each poem. Han Wo’s lyrical persona keeps the fruit of mei in her hands as an indication of her maturity and a hint at her being a woman from entertaining quarter15, while Li Qingzhao’s female character has a sprig of blooming mei in her hands, symbolizing her youth and beauty. This fresh and unusual image of youth and the description of falling in love for the first time is in sharp contrast to the imitative ci written by Li Qingzhao’s male contemporaries, who tried to describe the feelings in the female voice according to the established pattern. She did not compose her ci to entertain men as it was typical for Chinese ci culture before. She fundamentally revised the function of ci by expanding its thematic and stylistic range.
2.3 Poetic experiments
The modification of classical themes and images and as well as the introduction of love and erotic ci from a female perspective required the experiments with the composition of ci and their rhythmic and melodic structure to expand prosodic norms of this genre. Li Qingzhao made modifications in half of her early ci16, in particular, changing the balance between a level tone ping (平) and an oblique tone ze (仄), use of rhymes, the number of characters in a line and line divisions.
In Li Qingzhao’s early ci, two stanzas are not in opposition shifting the reader’s view from outside to inside as seen in ci composed by male poets. Instead of it, she used two different approaches to the composition of ci17. In one case, the first stanza mostly concerns a woman’s room while the second stanza describes what is happening outside; thus, there is no standard effect of approaching and “the lyric concerns a woman’s observations rather than the expression of her emotional state” (Blanchard, 2018, pp. 70–71). The second approach is overlooked by the researchers: there are some ci where the outside description changes into inside one (or vice versa) line by line, and it creates the effect of intertwined spaces at the same time correlating with a range of woman’s emotions.
Regarding modifications concerning the balance between tones, Li Qingzhao changed ping to ze in 16 lines and ze to ping in 12 lines. In Essay on Ci (詞論) she pointed out the specific features of ci distinguishing it from shi: “詩文分平側,而歌詞分五音，
又分五 聲，又分六律，又分清濁輕重” (“Shi distinguishes [tones] ping and ze, but ci distinguishes five yin, five sheng, six lü as well as qing/zhuo and qing/zhong [sounds]”) (Xu Peijun, 2009, p. 267)18. As she emphasized the importance of the right use of tones in ci, these numerous changes in their use may indicate her dissatisfaction with these cipu and attempts to change the standard for composing ci.
The next type of modification concerns the use of rhymes19. In most cases, the rhyme in ci corresponded to the musical pause (Xia Chengtao, Wu Xionghe, 2016, p. 8) and correlated with the expressing sentiments (p. 36). If the rhyming syllables are distributed too dense, the sentiments of ci are very fast and urgent; if they are very few, the sentiments are probably calm and slow (Rydholm, 1998, p. 80).
Ci to the tune Manifold Little Hills (小重山) is a good illustration of changing the sentiments in ci by changing the number of rhymes. According to cipu to this tune, there are 8 lines and 8 ping rhymes, so the rhymes are too dense, presupposing the expression of restless and anxious feelings. However, Li Qingzhao did not use a rhyme in the first line, thus changing not only cipu but also the sentiments of ci. If we compare her poem with ci to the same tune written by Xue Zhaoyun (薛昭蘊, 10th century), she borrowed the first line of his ci and did not use rhyme in it as he did. R. Egan points out that “the mood and substance of Li Qingzhao’s piece stands in sharp contrast to Xue Zhaoyun’s song” (2013, p. 383). In his ci “the loveliness of the spring night only intensifies the loneliness of the woman in her room” and “a sustained account of her misery and listlessness” (2013, p. 383). But woman in Li Qingzhao’s ci enjoys every moment of spring, she detects “how attractive everything is, both inside and outside” and focuses “on minute physical detail, and they are all pleasing” (2013, p. 383). However, R. Egan uses Li Qingzhao’s ci just as an example of various interpretations by different commentators, and the very way she achieved this effect has escaped his field of vision. However, it is precisely the absence of rhyme in the first line that leads to an emotional change in ci: Li Qingzhao’s ci is full of joy, and there is no hint of anxiety, loneliness and sorrow as in Xue Zhaoyun’s ci.
Unlike the majority of male and female poets of the Song dynasty, Li Qingzhao tried to go beyond traditional ideas about writing ci: she made changes not only in the use of conventional themes and images, introduced the love theme and romantic sentiments from a female perspective, but also revised the foundations of ci composition and their prosodic norms. Thus, she managed to create a new poetic language for ci, develop some rules for this genre and lay the foundation for her distinctive personal style – Yi’an style. The next articles will be devoted to the specific features of Li Qingzhao’s mature ci and the further evolution of her poetic style.
This article is a part of the research project №0119U100041 (2019-2021) in Oles’ Honchar Dnipro National University. It is partly based on a report presented at the Fourth International Conference on Chinese Studies “The Silk Road” (01-02 June 2017) organized by Confucius Institute at Sofia University “St. Kliment Ohridski” (Bulgaria). I am very grateful to Chiang Ching-kuo Foundation for International Scholarly Exchange (Taiwan) and European Association for Chinese Studies for their support and assistance in gathering the necessary material (Library Travel Grant, 2017). I am also thankful to the reviewers who provided insightful and helpful feedback.
Blanchard, L., 2018. Song dynasty figures of longing and desire: gender and interiority in Chinese painting and poetry. Leiden, Boston: Brill.
Bossler, B., 2013. Courtesans, concubines, and the cult of female fidelity. Cambridge, London: Harvard University Asia Center.
Chang, K., 1980. The evolution of Chinese tz’u poetry from late T’ang to Northern Sung. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
Chen Zumei 陈祖美, 1995. Li Qingzhao pingzhuan. 李清照评传 [A Critical Biography of Li Qingzhao]. Nanjing: Nanjing daxue chubanshe. [In Chinese].
Chen Zumei 陈祖美, 2003. Li Qingzhao ci xinshi jiping. 李清照词新释辑评 [New Interpretation of Li Qingzhao’s Ci with Commentaries]. Beijing: Zhongguo shudian. [In Chinese].
Chen Zumei 陳祖美, 2004. Li Qingzhao. 李清照 [Li Qingzhao]. Taipei: Zhishufang chuban jituan. [In Chinese].
Dashchenko, A., 2016. «Rassuzhdenija o cy» («詞論») Li Cinchzhao [“Essay on Ci” by Li Qingzhao]. Respectus Philologicus, 30 (35), pp. 35–44. Available at: <https://www.journals.vu.lt/respectus-philologicus/article/view/13578/12491> [Accessed 26 August 2021]. [In Russian].
Dashchenko, H., 2019. Emotions and Images in Li Qingzhao’s Ci Poetry: Quantitative Analysis. Respectus Philologicus, 36 (41), pp. 85–98. https://doi.org/10.15388/RESPECTUS.2019.36.41.25.
Djao, W., 2010. A blossom like no other: Li Qingzhao. Toronto, Ginger Post Inc.
Egan, R., 2006. The problem of beauty: aesthetic thought and pursuits in Northern Song Dynasty China. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
Egan, R., 2013. The burden of female talent: the poet Li Qingzhao and her history in China. Cambridge, London: Harvard University Asia Center.
Fong, G., 1990. Persona and mask in the song lyric (ci). Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies, 50 (2), pp. 459–484.
Fong, G., 2015. The burden of female talent: the poet Li Qingzhao and her history in China by Ronald Egan. Journal of Song-Yuan Studies, 45 (1), pp. 402–408.
Ho, L., 1968. More gracile than yellow flowers: the life and works of Li Ch’ing-chao. Hong Kong: Mayfair Press.
Hsu, K., 1994. The poems of Li Qingzhao (1084–1141). Images of women in Chinese literature. Li Yu-ning, ed. Indianapolis: University of Indianapolis Press.
Hu, P., 1966. Li Ch’ing-chao. NY: Twayne publishers, Inc.
Huang Huatong 黄华童, Cai Guoqiang 蔡国强, 2019. Shiyong tang song cipu. 实用唐宋词谱 [Poetic Meters of Ci in Tang and Song Dynasty: for Practical Use]. Beijing: Beijing daxue chubanshe. [In Chinese].
Idema, W., Grant, B., 2004. The red brush: writing women of imperial China. Cambridge: Harvard University Asia Center.
Ke Baocheng 柯宝成, 2009. Li Qingzhao quanji: huiping ben. 李清照全集：汇评本 [The Complete Works of Li Qingzhao: The Commentary]. Wuhan: Chongwen shuju. [In Chinese].
Li Xiuyun 李秀雲, 2012. 教師職業道路上的跋涉 [To Trudge along the Teacher’s Path]. Shenyang: Liaoning renmin chubanshe. [In Chinese].
Liu, J., 1962. The art of Chinese poetry. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Owen, S., 2019. Just a song: Chinese lyrics from the eleventh and early twelfth centuries. Cambridge, London: Harvard University Asia Center.
Pannam, C., 2009. Music from a jade flute. The ci poems of Li Qingzhao. Melbourne: Hybrid Publishers.
Rexroth, K., Chung, L., 1979. Li Ch’ing-chao. Complete poems. NY: New Directions Publishing.
Rouzer, P., 1993. Writing another’s dream: the poetry of Wen Tingyun. Stanford: Stanford University Press.
Rydholm, L., 1998. In search of the generic identity of Ci poetry. Doctoral dissertation. Stockholm: Stockholm University.
Rydholm, L., 2011. The Theory of Ancient Chinese Genres. Literary history: towards a global perspective. A. Pettersson, G. Lindberg-Wada, M. Petersson and S. Helgesson, eds. Berlin, Boston: De Gruyter, pp. 53–110. https://doi.org/10.1515/9783110894110.2.53.
Samei, M., 2004. Gendered persona and poetic voice: the abandoned woman in early Chinese song lyrics. Lanham: Lexington Books.
Shi Yidui 施议对, 1989. Ci yu yinyue guanxi yanjiu. 词与音乐关系研究. [Studies on the Relations between Ci and Music]. Beijing: Zhongguo shehui kexue chubanshe. [In Chinese].
Wang, J., 1989. The Complete Ci-poems of Li Qingzhao: A New English Translation. Sino-Platonic Papers, 13.
Wu Xionghe 吴熊和, 2003. Tangsong ci tonglun. 唐宋词通论. [An Introduction to Tang and Song Ci]. Beijing: Shangwu yinshuguan. [In Chinese].
Wu Zhangshu 吴丈蜀, 2016. Cixue gaishuo. 词学概说. [An Introduction to Ci Studies]. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju. [In Chinese].
Xia Chengtao 夏承焘, Wu Xionghe 吴熊和, 2016. Du ci changshi. 读词常识. [Reading Ci: General Knowledge]. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju. [In Chinese].
Xiang Meilin 向梅林, 2006. Yi’an ti dute fengge lun xi. 易安体独特风格论析. [Analysis of the Specificity of Yi’an Style]. 长沙大学学报. [Journal of Changsha University], 6, pp. 98–100. [In Chinese].
Xu Beiwen 徐北文, 2015. Li Qingzhao quanji pingzhu. 李清照全集评注. [Commentaries on the Complete Works of Li Qingzhao]. Jinan: Jinan chubanshe. [In Chinese].
Xu Peijun 徐培均, 2009. Li Qingzhao ji jianzhu. 李清照集箋注. [Commentaries on Li Qingzhao’s Works]. Shanghai: Shanghai guji chubanshe. [In Chinese].
Zhou Guifeng 周桂峰, 2002. Lun Yi’an ti de meixue gongxian. 论易安体的美学贡献. [On Aesthetics of Yi’an style]. 淮阴师范学院学报. [Journal of Huaiyin Normal University], 1, pp. 91–95. [In Chinese].
Zhuge Yibing 诸葛忆兵, 2004. Li Qingzhao yu Zhao Mingcheng. 李清照与赵明诚. [Li Qingzhao and Zhao Mingcheng]. Beijing: Zhonghua shuju. [In Chinese].
1 Such lists of the great male masters in different fields (poetry, philosophy, prose, calligraphy, etc.) are traditional for Chinese culture, e.g. “Eight Great Prose Masters of the Tang and Song Dynasties” (“唐宋八大家”), “Four Great Calligraphers of the Song Dynasty” (“宋四家”), etc. The lists of outstanding women have appeared since the Tang dynasty.
2 Yi’an style is derived from Li Qingzhao’s studio name Yi’an jushi (易安居士) (Chen Zumei, 1995, p. 37).
3 The dearth of studies on Li Qingzhao’s life and poetry outside China is indeed surprising. The first translations of her poetry into English did not appear until 1933 (by Clara Candlin). In 1960s, there were also two small books on her life and works published (Hu, 1966; Ho, 1968), but they had no academic impact as “interest in Li Qingzhao in the Western world turned to translate her small surviving corpus of song lyrics (ci 詞)”(Fong, 2015, p. 402).
4 Li Qingzhao’s collection Ci of Jades for Rinsing the Mouth (漱玉詞) was widely circulated during the Southern Song (南宋, 1127–1279), but it was lost as early as the 14th century (Egan, 2013, p. 92). Only some of her ci (from 2 to 8) were introduced in poetry anthologies compiled by the late 16th century. Ming editor Chen Yaowen (陳耀文) was the first one to include her 44 ci in his anthology A Refined Collection of Flowers and Grasses (花草粹編, circa 1580). There was an active search of ci and their publication during the Qing dynasty. There were about 9,000 ci written to 1540 different tunes in Ci through the Ages (歷代詩餘, 1707) compiled by Shen Zhanyuan (沈展垣) and Li Qingzhao was introduced by 38 ci. In 1888 Wang Pengyun (王鵬運) tried to reconstruct Li Qingzhao’s collection, where he presented her 57 ci (Egan, 2013, p. 98). Zhao Wangli (趙萬里) included 60 ci written by her in his anthology Revised Collection of Ci from the Song, Jin and Yuan Dynasties (校輯宋金元人詞, 1931). Tang Guizhang’s (唐圭璋) anthology The Complete Collection of Ci of the Song Dynasty (全宋詞, 1940) is the greatest one as it presents more than 21,000 Song ci with 47 ci written by Li Qingzhao and 26 ci attributed to her. The first individual collection of Li Qingzhao’s ci titled The Collection of Jades for Rinsing the Mouth (漱玉集) was compiled by Li Wenqi (李文椅) in 1927 with 78 ci.
5 For the detailed analysis and the commentaries on Li Qingzhao’s Essay on Ci see Egan, 2013, pp. 75–90; Dashchenko, 2016.
6 The number of tune patterns is really stunning: Kangxi Collection of Ci Tunes (欽定詞譜, late 17th – early 18th century) contains 826 cipu and 2306 of their variants.
7 Some scholars use the other classifications. Thus, ci are sometimes divided into only two kinds or sub-genres: 小令and 慢詞 (Hu, 1966, p. 19). The former “contains not more than 62 characters” while the latter “ranges roughly from 70 to 240 characters” (Chang, 1980, p. 212). Sometimes researchers mention four kinds (令, 引, 近 and 慢) according to their affinity to the four major “melody categories” (Rydholm, 1998, p. 45; Xia Chengtao, Wu Xionghe, 2016, pp. 36–39). There is also a classification of nine ci forms
(法曲, 大曲, 慢曲, 引, 近, 序子, 三台, 纏令, 諸宮調) which is also directly connected to the kinds of ci melodies (Shi Yidui, 1989, p. 189; Rydholm, 1998, p. 46). Some modern Chinese scholars point out that dividing ci into types by the number of characters is not right, as a lot of ci do not fall under this classification (Wu Xionghe, 2003, p. 94).
8 Such composition (from describing what is happening outside to depicting the inner chamber and a woman alone) in Tang erotic poetry is considered as penetration, because “for the male poets there is no qualitative difference between exposing a woman’s bedroom, her body, and her mind” (Rouzer, 1993, p. 74).
9 This thematic division is very often pointed out as one of the distinguishing features between ci and the dominant shi genre
(詩). Lena Rydholm emphasizes that it should be considered as the standard cliché where “shi express ideals, ci express emotions”
(“詩言志, 詞言情”), but “this division is artificial, since there are many love-poems written in shi-form” (2011, p. 101). However, she agrees that “ci-poetry for the main part dealt with ‘private’ themes like love/eroticism, while shi-poetry often dealt with ‘public’ themes such as politics, ethics and philosophy” (2011, p. 101). Ronald Egan also mentions that “romantic love tends to be a marginal subject in shi poetry” because of the dominant paradigm, namely: “the traditional association between that form and the ideal of a poet ‘stating his intent’ as a Confucian scholar or official in service of the state (or as a recluse, a man who rebelled against that abiding model)” (2006, p. 239).
10 As to the other forms, there are 4 zhongdiao (18.18%) and 3 changdiao (13.64%). For the detailed quantitative analysis of Li Qingzhao’s ci see Dashchenko, 2019.
11 In particular, a lot of xiaoling being in circulation at that time are linked to the names of Feng Yansi (馮延巳, 903–960) and Yan Jidao (晏幾道, 1030?–1106?) (Owen, 2019, pp. 11–13). In Essay on Ci (詞論), Li Qingzhao mentioned these poets as those who appreciated the elegant lines and their ci were considered unusually refined and original (Xu Peijun, 2009, p. 271).
12 Han Wo’s poem is almost twice as long as hers (60 characters).
13 Ci to the tunes Dabbing Crimson Lips (點絳唇), The Vile Charmer (醜奴兒), Sand of Silk-washing Stream (浣溪沙), Short Version. Magnolia Flower (減字木蘭花), Waves Wash the Sand (浪淘沙).
14 These ci are not “attested in any extant Song or Yuan source” and “it is not until the late Ming that their existence, one by one, gradually becomes established” (Egan, 2013, p. 358). All of them were included in different highly respected Qing poetry collections as those written by Li Qingzhao. In most cases, only modern commentators call the authorship of these ci in question. The reasons are the following: “it is unlikely that a woman with Li Ch’ing-chao’s status and family background would write such a poem” (Rexroth, Chung 1979, p. 97); “the content is unworthy of a woman of her moral status”, “the poet expresses her love boldly in defiance of the feudal shackles of her day” (Wang, 1989, p. 43); “此词过分轻薄”, “清照青年时, 不可能有此约会” (“this ci is too frivolous”, “it was impossible for her to have such a tryst”) (Ke Baocheng, 2009, p. 94); “<…> 明系男子之感受, 与女性之心态不同, 定非易安所作” (“it expresses the feelings of a man not of a woman, it was certainly not written by Yi’an”) (Xu Beiwen, 2015, p. 140), etc.
15 This conclusion can be reached, firstly, by the contents and style of Han Wo’s erotic poems, which are rather explicit and sensual, and, secondly, by the symbolic meaning of mei in Chinese culture: starting from Shijing (詩經) this fruit in girl’s hands is considered as a symbol of female genitals and usually interpreted as flirting to a young man or lovemaking (Li Xiuyun, 2012, pp. 153–154).
16 I have used Huang Huatong, Cai Guoqiang, 2019 and Xu Beiwen, 2015 to compare zhengti with the patterns of her ci.
17 There are also some ci where both stanzas concern only outside description, but all of them deal with the praise of different flowers.
18 Modern scholars find it difficult to determine what Li Qingzhao meant by these rules and how exactly they should have been applied. Xia Chengtao and Wu Xionghe tried to find an explanation for some of these terms: five yin ( 五音) mean five classes of initials (glottal, dental, alveolar, lateral, labial); five sheng (五聲) mean five tones – “female” ping (陰平), “male” ping (陽平), shang (上), qu (去) and ru (入); qing (清) should be understood as a male (closed) syllable and zhuo (濁) as a female (open) syllable (2016, p. 67). Regarding the other terms mentioned by Li Qingzhao the researchers did not make any assumptions.
19 There are three ci with rhyme modifications: in ci to the tune Manifold Little Hills (小重山) Li Qingzhao did not use rhyme according to cipu; in ci to the tune Short Version. Magnolia Flower (減字木蘭花) she changed the tone of the rhyme from ze to ping; in ci to the tune The Auspicious Partridge (瑞鷓鴣) she used two different types of ping rhymes, which “与词体不合” (“should not be done in ci genre”) (Xu Beiwen, 2015, p. 309).