The article investigates the philosophical meaning of poetical paradoxes in Hesiod's Theogony. The research differentiates between conventional, formulaic poetics of the Greek epic tradition and Hesiod's individual poetic strategies. In order to prove that Hesiod is a poet in the Greek sense of the word, i.e. an author of distinct personality and views, it is important to show that he goes far beyond the convention of traditional epic language that lacks in expression. First, the article presents an overview of the research made by different international scholars who argue for Hesiod's poetic originality and subtlety (the works of G. Nagy, C. Calame, G. S. Kirk, R. Lamberton and M. L. West are especially valuable in this respect). Moreover, it is stressed that the scholar of ancient philosophy, F. M. Cornford, has argued that Hesiod's theogony has much in common with the first Milesian cosmogonies, which are traditionally considered to be the very beginnings of Greek and Western philosophy. Following the discussion on the present state of Hesiodic studies, an attempt is made to link Hesiod's poetical language to his general world outlook and philosophical views. It is argued that the poetical and the philosophical layers in Theogony are closely interconnected. The article also deals with the issue of how Hesiod's passive, receptive attitude towards the Muses (if one accepts that the revelation of the Muses to Hesiod is a real fact rather than a poetic fiction) could be reconciled with his poetical originality, creative activeness and his apparent attempts to suggest a radical reinterpretation of the Greek mythological tradition. This paradox is resolved by drawing the reader's attention to the fact that the divine information passively received from the Muses becomes the source (origo, to put it in Latin) of Hesiod's poetical originality and creative activeness. The divine information provides Hesiod with the access to a richer and more interesting source of inspiration than the realm of common poetical convention. Having resolved the first paradox, the author of the article deals with the second, namely the fact that the gods of the older generation are portrayed as beautiful by way of their ugliness, i.e. they are considered to be beautiful not despite of, but because of their horrific ugliness. This fact is of great philosophical importance. Hesiod's poetic strategy is based on the identification of the divine beauty with the divine ugliness, which imbues the poem with strange poetic charm, thus achieving a purely aesthetic result. Furthermore, it features a profound philosophical dimension, which makes it possible for Hesiod to reject the archaic, pre-Olympian mythology in a subtle, ironic way, avoiding the explicit recourse to didacticism. The manner whereby Hesiod negates the absurd mythology and superstition of the Dark Ages in Classical Antiquity is, paradoxically, not didactic at all (contrary to what we could expect of the author of the didactic poem, The Works and Days). The conclusion is made that the nature of Hesiod's poetic strategy and the famous Hesiodic irony, which is also briefly discussed in the article, makes a case for Hesiod's subtlety and poetical originality.

Šis darbas apsaugotas Creative Commons priskyrimo 4.0 viešąja licencija.